skip navigation
skip mega-menu

The end of the workaround: why 2027 will bring the flexible workforce into core HR

The end of the workaround: why 2027 will bring the flexible workforce into core HR

For decades, employers have managed casual, bank, sessional and event workers outside core HR, in booking tools, spreadsheets and agency portals, because it was quick and the rules were light. That era is ending. Between April 2026 and 2027, right-to-work duties, statutory sick pay, holiday records, sponsored pay and new zero-hours rights all reach the flexible workforce, and enforcement increasingly relies on data. Our view is that by the end of 2027, any organisation still running its flexible workforce outside core HR will be carrying compliance risk it cannot see. 

Every large employer has one. Sometimes it is a departmental spreadsheet. Sometimes it is a casual-worker booking app, a bank-staff system or an agency portal. Its purpose is the same: to get people working quickly without going through the full machinery of HR. 

For a long time, that workaround made sense. Our argument is that it has stopped making sense, and that 2027 is the year most organisations will feel it. 

How did the flexible workforce end up outside HR? 

The separation was rarely a strategy. It accumulated for practical reasons: 

  • Speed. Departments and wards needed to book people today, not after a week of HR process. 

  • Local budgets. Flexible labour was often paid from local funds and managed by local managers. 

  • Lighter obligations. Many rules applied mainly to employees, so casual workers seemed lower risk. 

  • System limits. Older HR systems struggled with one person holding several roles, so separate tools filled the gap. 

The result, in many organisations, is a workforce of two halves: a well-governed core and a flexible fringe that is visible only through payroll. 

What has changed? 

In little more than eighteen months, the rules have moved decisively towards the flexible workforce: 

  • April 2026: statutory sick pay became payable from day one with the lower earnings limit removed, bringing many low-hours workers into scope, and employers became obliged to keep holiday records for six years. 

  • April 2026: sponsored workers became subject to pay checks in every pay period, with the Home Office able to see HMRC payroll data. 

  • 1 October 2026: right-to-work duties extended beyond employees to agency, casual, zero-hours and contracted workers. 

  • 2027 (expected): qualifying zero-hour and low-hours workers gain rights to guaranteed hours offers, reasonable notice of shifts and payment for short-notice cancellations. 

Each change on its own could be absorbed with a process tweak. Together they remove the premise of the workaround: that flexible workers carry lighter obligations. 

Why is "good enough" no longer good enough? 

Three shifts sit underneath the individual rules. 

Obligations now follow the person, not the contract type. Whether someone is an employee, a worker, a bank nurse or a student on a casual contract matters less than it did. Right to work, sick pay, holiday records and visa limits apply across them. 

Evidence must exist at the time. Guaranteed hours offers depend on hours worked over a reference period. Short-notice payments depend on when a shift was published and when it was cancelled. Those facts cannot be reconstructed reliably from a spreadsheet months later. 

Regulators increasingly see the data. When payroll submissions feed immigration checks, errors in the flexible fringe become visible outside the organisation, often before they are visible inside it. 

The workaround that only appears in payroll was tolerable when the main risk was administrative. It is far less tolerable when the risk is a sponsor licence, a Fair Work Agency investigation or an unbudgeted wave of short-notice payments. 

What does the alternative look like? 

The answer is not to make flexible work as slow as permanent recruitment. It is to hold one workforce with many kinds of working relationship: 

  • One person record for everyone who works for the organisation, whatever their contract type. 

  • Each engagement as its own assignment beneath that person, with its own rate, manager, cost centre and dates. 

  • Booking and rostering connected to that record, so hours, right-to-work status and visa limits are checked when work is offered, not after it is paid. 

  • Fast, light journeys for flexible work, so managers can still book people quickly within the same governed system. 

This does not necessarily mean one vendor for everything. Specialist booking or rostering tools can remain the front end where they work well. What matters is that there is one authoritative record per person, and that the rules run against it. 

Isn't this more expensive? 

It can look that way, because consolidation has a visible cost and the workaround's costs are hidden. Those hidden costs include rekeying timesheets into payroll, reconciling separate systems, duplicated right-to-work checks or missed ones, and the time spent assembling evidence when someone asks. From 2027, they will also include short-notice payments and guaranteed hours offers calculated by hand. 

Our experience is that once those costs are counted honestly, the business case for bringing the flexible workforce into core HR is usually stronger than leaders expect. 

What should leaders do in the next 12 months? 

  1. Find every workaround. List every system, spreadsheet and portal used to book, pay or check flexible workers. 

  1. Count the people, not the records. Identify how many people hold more than one role across those systems. 

  1. Test one obligation end to end. Pick a rule, such as right-to-work for casual staff, and check whether you could evidence it for every worker today. 

  1. Model 2027. Run recent rota data through the zero-hours proposals to estimate offers and payments. 

  1. Set a target architecture. Decide which record will be authoritative and which tools will feed it. 

What do we expect to see by 2028? 

This is our view of where the market is heading: 

  • Casual-worker booking tools will increasingly operate as front ends to core HR rather than as separate systems of record. 

  • "Worker", not "employee", will become the unit HR systems are designed around. 

  • Payroll and HR will share ownership of compliance controls, with checks moving from audit into everyday booking and approval. 

  • Organisations that consolidate early will treat the 2027 reforms as a configuration exercise. Those that do not will treat them as a crisis. 

We help organisations bring salaried, casual, bank and sessional workers onto one HR and payroll platform, with compliance designed into the way work is booked. If your flexible workforce still lives outside core HR, we would be glad to discuss what bringing it in would involve. 

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up here